Jump to content
The mkiv Supra Owners Club

Intel or AMD? PC self build


foggy147

Recommended Posts

Hi guys, over the next few months I am going to start purchasing bits to build my own desktop computer. Before I start I obviously need to decide what parts I will get and make sure they are all compatable with each other.

 

My first main question is whether to choose the AMD route or the intel route? My overall budget will be around 600 without monitor,keyboard etc, purely just to build the base unit.

 

I am wanting to build a computer that is going to beable to run pretty much any pc game to date at full settings

 

Here is a brief outline as to the spec I am aiming for

 

6GB DDR 3 RAM

Processor -still deciding

Motherboard - depends on what processor I choose

Graphics card - FX ATI Radeon 5770 HD 1GB PCI-Express 2.0 x16 Dual DVI HDMI Eyefinity

65 GB SSD SATA drive for OS

500gb hard drive

ATX Case

Couple of cooling case fans

DVD RW or blue ray drive

Semi decent sound card

Wireless connectivity

 

Any advice if this would be a good spec to play decent games and for future proof upgrading?

 

Cheers

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I love AMD I truly do and whilst they are considerably cheaper than Intel's offerrings I still think it is worth paying out the extra, I am still on my Intel Q6600 which is my first Intel and really wanted to go over to the 6 core AMD black but performance wise I don't think it is there.

For anyone on even half a budget you want to be after the new sandbridge I5 processors. 3.2GHz stock speed and 4.5GHz or higher overclock possible on air.

 

Even if you haven't touched overclocking before as long as you can hit page up a few times in the BIOS and save you are sorted.

 

http://www.overclockers.co.uk/pimg/CP-360-IN_400.jpg

http://www.overclockers.co.uk/showproduct.php?prodid=CP-360-IN&groupid=701&catid=6&subcat=1275

 

- Unlocked Multiplier

- Lithography Process: 32 nm

- Cores: 4

- Threads: 4

- Frequency: 3.30 GHz (Turbo Mode 3.70GHz)

- Integrated HD 3000 (12 EUs) Graphics

- Integrated Graphics Frequency: 850MHz (1100MHz Turbo)

- Cache: 6 MB shared L3

- Memory Controller: Dual channel DDR3 800/1066/1333/1600 MHz

- TDP: 95W

- Socket: LGA1155

- Compatible with Socket 1156 heatsinks

- 3yr Warranty

 

As for graphics I have 2 5770s and they run pretty much anything but for a single card I would look at Nvidias 460 or 470 series.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

http://www.dabs.com/basket.aspx?ul=1&page=/category/components-and-storage,cases--cooling-and-power/11023

 

Not sure if this works but a rough idea of what sort of spec, any good?

 

 

TI Radeon 5770 HD 1GB PCI-Express 2.0 x16 Dual DVI HDMI Eyefinity

Quicklinx:6Z1SWS | Mfr#:HD-577X-ZNFC

 

In stock

£94.99 £94.99

 

XFX 650W 80+ Bronze Certified Single Rail

Quicklinx:75R9WS | Mfr#:P1-650S-NLB9

 

In stock

£65.13 £65.13

 

LiteOn 24x DVD-RW Internal Black SATA Retail Box

Quicklinx:64YSWS | Mfr#:IHAS324-32

 

In stock

£21.34 £21.34

 

D-Link 802.11g Wireless LAN PCI Card

Quicklinx:43C0WS | Mfr#:DWL-G510

 

In stock

£18.54 £18.54

 

Akasa Zen-Black Silent Midi ATX Case

Quicklinx:49R2WS | Mfr#:AK-ZEN01V4-BK

 

In stock

£42.58 £42.58

Bundle details for the Asus P8P67 PRO & 4GB RAM £339.98 £339.98 You save £9.99

 

Asus Intel 2nd Generation P67 Bundle (Includes P8P67 PRO Motherboard & Core i5-2500 3.30GHz Processor)

Quicklinx:79RCWS | Mfr#:ASUSINTEL-BUN04

 

In stock 1

£293.00 £293.00

 

Corsair Memory Vengeance 4GB DDR3 1600MHz CL9 XMP

Quicklinx: 79V5WS | Mfr: CMZ4GX3M1A1600C

 

In stock 1

£46.98 £46.98

Bundle details for the CTG SATA Cable Bundle £91.48 £91.48 You save £1.49

 

Crucial 64GB RealSSD C300 2.5" SSD SATA 6Gb/s

Quicklinx:7246WS | Mfr#:CTFDDAC064MAG-1

 

In stock 1

£88.84 £88.84

 

CablesToGo 1m 180° To 90° 7 pin Serial ATA Cable

Quicklinx: 63TBWS | Mfr: 81825

 

In stock 1

£2.64 £2.64

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I was pro-AMD for years. I switched from Intel to AMD when the K6 came out, over 15 years ago, and I've stuck with them ever since. That is... Until the Intel Core i5 came out. Now that's one amazing bang-for-buck CPU, and - as others have stated - the overclocking potential on them is truly immense.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Foggy, unless you really can't push to it, go Intel. They are far superior right now. The i5/i7's are in a class of their own and even if you can't afford an i7, you can push an i5 to the i7 stock level anyway with some decent air cooling. ATI and Nvidia are pretty much on a par so any of their top end cards will be more than than a match for any current games. I favour Nvidia but only through personal choice.

 

Do yourself a favour though, don't skimp out on your PC case. I used to cram top end gear into a shitty £20 job and could only just about hold stable temps at stock speeds. I recently transplanted my components into a new Nzxt Phantom case and I've now got a Q6600 Quad running at 3.6ghz with better temps than at 2.4ghz in the old case. It makes all the difference.

 

You can see the case here: http://www.mkivsupra.net/vbb/showthread.php?234832-Nzxt-Phantom-Case-install-complete

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I used to enjoy these threads (ex-geek :D).

 

I've attached what I would put together for a gaming system with a rough budget of £600. I could not put in an SSD for that price, and I wouldn't reduce anything to get one (especially not the graphics card!).

 

Sandy Bridge blows everything out of the water, and unless you're on a very tight budget it doesn't make sense to go for anything else. The 2500/2500K is generally considered the 'sweet spot' of the range (if you plan on using the on-board graphics or overclocking at any point, get the K, else you could get the non-K). I picked an H67 motherboard as they're slightly cheaper (and personally I intend on using the built in GPU for transcoding), I don't see the need for overclocking CPUs now as they're already ridiculously fast - but it is very easy to do if you wish to.

 

4GB RAM is enough for everything you're likely to chuck at it, nothing special about the kit I've selected. I doubt it's cutting edge but it's not slow either.

 

I've gone for a Radeon 5870 graphics card, which is at the high end of the 'last-gen' product line. The new ATi range did not offer any huge improvements and performance is very similar to the 6950 for a lot less money - it's a no brainer (especially as you seem to be considering a 20"+ 1920x1080 monitor).

 

A popular modular Antec PSU is my choice for power, and a similarly popular Antec case (which I've always found very solid), you may find other options you prefer.

 

The Samsung F3 hard drive has always been very fast, it may have been overtaken but I'm not going review hunting for you - for £40 you can't go wrong.

 

Optical drive and wireless cards are just whatever I happened to click on first, personally I use an optical drive to install windows and pretty much never touch it again - if you expect to use it a lot it may be worth checking out reviews. Wireless.. well I'll leave that up to you, personally I'd try and rig up an ethernet connection if you're expecting to do some online gaming.

 

You haven't mentioned it in your previous posts but do you also need to purchase an operating system? You're looking at about £100 for Windows 7 Home Premium, which you may need to consider in your budget.

 

Happy hunting, enjoy your build.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

intel all the way... I just feel as intel specialize in just chips there one to go for AMD get involved with other bits..

 

Erm.. flawed logic there ;)

 

AMD and Intel both do chips (and chip design) and very different designs as well.. Intel atom, their arm variation... etc..

 

That said AMD / Intel have slightly different implementations, one being quicker on mem access, and the other being a quicker calculator...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Sub £600 - AMD, £600+ Intel.

 

Chip of the moment is as its been mentioned the new 1155 socket Intel i5 2500K. The K's clock very nicely and are about £10 more. Stock and prices are very hit and miss at the moment so shop around.

 

This is what I think of sandy bridge: Sandy Bridge Custom PC.

 

Going over your spec with parts you should address;

 

Power supply is not great, get a corsair Unit Ideally the TX series (650TX FTW).

Bin that case! Stick with an Antec, Corsair, Collermaster or Xigmatek. A good budget choice would be the Antec 300 (add two 120 intake fans) or Xigmatek Asgard, Midgard or Utgard.

 

The CPU in that bundle is not a K series

 

P8P67 PRo - Do you need the pro version, the standard P8P67 has 90% of the features the Pro has.

 

An ATI 5770, whilst it is a good card as it is, is not going to 'run the latest games without breaking a sweat'. Budget £150+ for a decent video card. A GTX 460 1GB would be a suitable choice but is set to be replaced by a GTX 560 in the next few days (The 560 will probably be out of your budget though). ATI 5850's are good cards but are old tech (replaced by 6870's) but can be had on the cheap.

 

If you find a decent video card is tipping you over try an I5 2300 CPU. It keeps you on the 1155 platform with room to upgrade later down the line but forget overclocking, it will still Turbo a little from 2.8Ghz to 3.1Ghz on its tod.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Change of plan as not wanting to spend so much! Still getting an i5, and going to leave the graphics card out for the moment and just build it up and install the graphics card when i get paid next month so i can get a top end one. One question though- if I was to buy this:

 

http://www.dabs.com/products/asus-intel-performance-bundle--includes-asus-p7p55d-e-lx-motherboard---intel-core-i5-760-2-8-ghz-cpu--73GZ.html?refs=443260000

 

Can I connect this to it without a graphics card installed?

 

http://www.dabs.com/products/viewsonic-vx2239wm-22--1920-x-1080--full-hd-lcd-tft-with-2ms-vga-dvi-d-hdmi-monitor-77T8.html

 

I understand I wont beable to connect it through HD but as long as I can connect it any other way for the time being...

 

Cheers

Link to comment
Share on other sites

That bundle you've highlighted does not have onboard graphics, and is also last-gen tech. The board I put up in my original post will allow you to use the graphics onboard the i5 (the 'K' chips have faster onboard graphics) however they will be almost useless for gaming.

 

Why not just wait until you have enough funds and do some proper research in the mean time?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue. You might also be interested in our Guidelines, Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.